web analytics
3 Flares Filament.io 3 Flares ×

Daring Bakers

This is my first challenge as a daring baker, and it really was a fun one!!

And since I have a few friends and family members that read my blog that don’t frequent other food blogs, here is a little bit of history….

The Daring Bakers was started by two of my favorite food blogs – Lis of La Mia Cucina (every one of her blog posts makes me laugh) and Ivonne of Cream Puffs in Venice (talk about some serious baking talent!!) They both decided to make the same recipe one month – pretzels – using the same recipe, and post about it. The next month they decided to do it again with a different recipe, and had a few more join, and the next month they decided to do it again with a different recipe, and had a few more join, and the next month they decided to do it again with a different recipe, and a few more joined….you get the point!! The group has grown so large now that for the first time this month – a new blog has been created to give links to all of the participants for the month.

So without any further ado, this months challenge…..

Strawberry Mirror Cake | www.tasteandtellblog.com

A Strawberry Mirror Cake

I had never had a strawberry mirror cake before, in fact, I don’t think I had ever heard of one before. I was really excited to try something new. I was going to make it at the beginning of the month, but put it off for a bit because of my hubby’s birthday and other things that were going on. I decided that I had the perfect opportunity to make it for my family’s once-a-month get together. In fact, I’ve decided that my family might be getting the fruits of my daring baker labors every month when we get together. Who else would be the perfect guinea pigs that would give me honest opinions??

I read through the recipe multiple times, then headed to the store to pick up the ingredients I would need. Unfortunately, I already knew that I wouldn’t be able to find any local, wonderful strawberries. Our season here was just past, and I had spent the weekend before running to multiple stores and fruit stands, trying to find the perfect strawberries to top my husband’s cheesecake, but I had no luck. So I settled on some beautiful strawberries that lacked a lot of flavor. I even purchased a 10-inch springform pan for the recipe so that I could make sure it was right, and I was finally able to find cake flour. Really, who thought it would be so hard to find cake flour??? I had already volunteered to bring a dessert to the above mentioned family get together, so I knew there was no backing out – especially since I had already told a few of my sisters about it and they were looking forward to seeing how it turned out. I was quite lazy the night before, and didn’t start until about 8pm.

Everything started out very smoothly. I used my new toy to whip up the cake, which was probably my favorite component of the dessert. It is a thin cake, baked on a jelly roll pan, and then the two circles of cake that you use are cut out of the sheet cake. At first I wondered what I was going to do with all of the leftover cake scraps, but after tasting it, I knew it probably wouldn’t last long. I kept snacking on pieces while I made the cake (I needed the energy to keep me going, right?!?) and I finished them off the next day while I was making the mirror for the cake. (It was super tasty with the strawberry mush that was left over while making the mirror the next day!!)

First step – completed successfully.

Then came the strawberry Bavarian cream. This was my first time making a Bavarian cream, and although it wasn’t a complete success, or failure for that matter, I did learn a lot!! You first have to sprinkle gelatin over strawberry puree. I’ve used gelatin before, but this called for 2 1/2 tablespoons!! That seemed like a lot, but I went with it. I continued with the recipe, making the custard-like sauce. Everything went smoothly until I tried to stir in the gelatin/strawberry puree mixture. LUMPS GALORE!! I didn’t know what to do!! I tried to squish as many as I could against the side of the bowl, but there was no way I was going to get rid of all of them. (The next day I posted an entry on the daring bakers blog (a spot for us to discuss the recipe) and many other said they had the same problem, but just strained the mixture to get rid of the extra balls. I wish I would have thought of that!!) And then you are supposed to stir the mixture in a bowl over a bowl of ice water, but of course we didn’t have any ice because our freezer is so stinkin’ full, and it was too late in the recipe to run out and get some. So I tried to improvise, sticking some ice packs in the bowl of water, but that didn’t really work. So I stuck it in the fridge, stirring it every couple minutes – which is probably another reason I didn’t get rid of all of those little balls of gelatin. I continued on with the recipe without any problems – assembling the cake, I didn’t have any issues. Some had said that they ran out of room in their pan and couldn’t use all of the Bavarian cream, but I had tons of room to spare. The only modification I made (which was an allowed modification) was to leave the alcohol out. Into the fridge the cake went – and a look around the kitchen – now aka “war zone” – told me that I wasn’t going to bed quite yet. Lots of clean up later, I collapsed into bed along side my husband, who was already sound asleep thanks to the use of ear plugs!!

The next morning, before I started the mirror, I called my sister to see what time we were getting together, and told her that I would be making some cookies or cupcakes to bring as a back up. I was afraid that the gelatin balls would gross everyone out and that no one would want to eat my cake, but she told me that she had a birthday cake for her daughter, who’s birthday was that day. Thank goodness – the pressure was now off of me. So I continued. I was a little afraid of the mirror, as it also calls for gelatin, but luckily, everything went really smoothly. For the strawberry juice, you are supposed to drain the crushed, simmered strawberries through a “damp jelly bag or a cheesecloth-lined colander”. Well, I don’t even know what a damp jelly bag is, and I didn’t have any cheesecloth, so I improvised again, using an dish towel set over a colander, where the juice dripped into a bowl. I am happy to say, this worked wonderfully! Then there was another step with an ice bath – what to do this time?? Improvising again, I knew the ice packs wouldn’t cut it, so instead of ice, I used some frozen peas! Perfection! So next time you are out of ice and you need it for an ice bath, frozen peas work in a pinch! I decided that the only decoration I was going to do would be to set some sliced strawberries on top of the cake with the mirror on top, so I did that and then poured the mirror mixture on top. I made sure to pour very slowly, as I didn’t want it splashing everywhere, making a mess and becoming uneven. I went on beautifully!! I carried it to the fridge and set it down, then poked some small air bubbles with my fingernail to pop them. The cake was done!!

When the cake was unveiled that evening, everyone oohed and aahed about how pretty it was. It really was a gorgeous cake. After taking pictures, I dug into my slice.

The Pros:

  • Beautiful cake. It looks like something you would buy in a fancy bakery.
  • It wasn’t too hard to make, and I think that making it again would be a lot more successful, knowing exactly what needs to be done now.


The Cons:

  • Mine did not have a whole lot of flavor. I am not blaming this on the recipe – I am putting all of the fault on the strawberries. I think that if I would have caught them when it was prime season here in Utah, this cake would have been full of flavor. But even the raw strawberries that I ate were not that great.
  • There was not enough cake, which was my favorite component of the dessert. My finished product was a lot more cream than cake, and I would make the cake at least equal to the amount of cream.
  • It took a long time to make – about 3 hours – and maybe it would have been more worth it if it had more flavor.


The family liked it – but when they heard that it took 3 hours to make, they said that it wasn’t really worth 3 hours of work. But really, it was a great experience, and a lot of fun to make. This is so different than anything that I have ever made before, so it really was a learning experience, too.

I am including photos of my steps along the way – excuse the poor quality. It was late, and most were taken with one hand – sometimes my left hand, even though I am right handed!!

For the recipe, please visit Peabody’s blog. Thanks for the challenge Peabody!!

You can find the links of the other participants here. I’m excited to see how it turned out for everyone else!!

3 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 Pin It Share 3 Google+ 0 Email -- Filament.io 3 Flares ×
twitter fb fb fb

48 Responses to Strawberry Mirror Cake

  1. Tart Reform says:

    Wow, this really does look like something you would get in a professional bakery! If I brought this to a dinner party I don’t think anyone would believe that it was home made! Well done. You may have just convinced me to officially join the group!

  2. Kelly-Jane says:

    Well done with your first challenge! It looks great, I like the strawberries set into the mirror, really pretty :)

  3. gilly says:

    Way to go on your first challenge! I just love the embedded strawberries, such a lovely touch! Congrats!

  4. Alice Q. says:

    ha ha – I love your step by step photos! I feel the same way about the gelatin. So far yours is also the only other one I’ve seen to sink fruit in the mirror topping – great minds think alike :-) Congrats on your 1st challenge!

  5. Andrea says:

    Lovely! You did a terrific job!

  6. Janet says:

    Yours looks beautiful. The pea ice bath was hilarious!

  7. Mandy says:

    wow Deborah,
    thanks for the detailed account! and the frozen pea tips :)
    your cake looks beautiful.

  8. veron says:

    Congrats on a challenge well executed. Those strawberries in the mirror look awesome.

  9. Dagmar - A Cat in the Kitchen says:

    I loved the slide show! The cake looks great!

  10. kellypea says:

    Nice job. I love all the pictures of the steps. I usually take a ton of photos, but then don’t post them all. I’m still trying to work through how to organize it. This is a terrific way to do that.

    Yes, the LUMPS. I will always remember that part. I could feel the twinges of panic….It was pretty funny.

    And the war zone is totally true. I make a complete mess of my kitchen on this one. The only thing that made it better was that our challenge wasn’t a chocolate one!

  11. Pille says:

    Lovely cake, but I agree with you -a bit too much effort and too many eggs for this cake :) Love the strawberries in the mirror!! Congrats on successfully completing the first DB challenge!

  12. Sara says:

    The bavarian cream was a bit of a pain, wasn’t it. Too bad your strawberries didn’t have good flavor.

  13. Nazca says:

    Great first challenge. I put my bowl in the sink, and filled it with ice water. It meant the kitchen willed up with dirty bowls and cutlery while it rested but it was a small price to pay :-)

  14. breadchick says:

    This is a lovely cake! Nice job on your first challenge. It is perfect!

  15. Meeta says:

    Well this is a great first challenge and you did a fantastic job! Way to go!

  16. Hilda says:

    Your cake looks perfect! mine had strawberry chunks in it which made it sag in the middle, each with his own problem right? it was my first challenge too, I think we did well for ourselves… =)

  17. Laura says:

    I love the strawberries in the mirror too! The whole thing looks fantastic, great tip on the frozen peas (I used a dishcloth to drain the strawberry juice too)!

  18. Cheryl says:

    Your mirror is flawless. I love the picture of your kitchen too.

  19. Poonam says:

    Hi, I am here for the first time! The cake looks delicious!

  20. JennDZ - The Leftover Queen says:

    Nice job on your cake! Congrats on your first challenge!

    Now that I think about it, mine didn’t have a really strong strawberry flavor either – which is just as well, as I am not a big fan!

    I served mine for a family gathering too! Too much work not to have it enjoyed by all!

  21. Anh says:

    Deborah. great job on the cake.

    I think the mirror is a great decoration to the cake. My friend thinks the cream is enough for flavour. he even suggests to do a chocolate mirror. *LOL*. but I love the red mirror much better. :)

  22. Elle says:

    Great minds think alike! You used peas in the ice bath & I used limas. I agree with your pros and cons, although I lucked out and had tasty berries, so the cake was fairly yummy. I also didn’t strain my puree, so more flavor went into the bavarian cream that way. Your cake is beautiful and great for the dinner party!

  23. Anne says:

    Lovely! The step by step photos were cool. You did well on your first challenge :)

  24. Ivonne says:

    Congratulations on your first challenge! You did a great job on the cake!

  25. Mary says:

    You did a stellar job on your very first challenge. And you got the play with your new KA too!

  26. Chris says:

    Great first challenge!!! Way to go!

  27. Anita says:

    Wonderful for your first effort – welcome to the Daring Bakers!

  28. Amrita says:

    Hey! I agree on the comment you made about the lack of flavour…!

    It doesnt matter though, cos your cake looks stunning!

  29. KJ says:

    Your cake looks lovely. Mine was a bit bland as well. Thank goodness for the strawberry jelly.

  30. Inne says:

    Deborah, your cake looks great. Like you, I had to improvise sometimes – to strain the strawberry juice I used a sieve lined with a handkerchief. Which worked beautifully.

  31. Lis says:

    AWESOME Deborah!!! I loved how you told us about each step and the pros and cons.. and I really loved the slide show at the end. :D

    Lumpy or not, your cake is gorgeous!

    xoxo

  32. Tara says:

    Your cake looks gorgeous! Congratulations and welcome to the Daring Bakers :)

  33. Connie says:

    i agree… there should have been a bigger cake to cream ratio. and maybe if there was a layer of strawberry jam in the middle. hmm… i sense some tweaking….

  34. Rachel says:

    it looks pretty!

  35. Heather says:

    I really like the strawberries on top. Good job on your first challenge.

  36. Patricia Scarpin says:

    It looks so good, Deb!
    I haven’t made the challenge, but all the time I looked at the photo I thought there should be more cake as well – good to know you feel the same way!

  37. Belinda says:

    Goodness, you all did such an amazing job with this cake…your step by step photo tutorial is a seriously “icing on the cake” touch. :-) Beautiful, beautiful cake!

  38. Tartelette says:

    Congrats on your first challenge. My strawberries were not great either and you are right, it does make a difference in the final product. I love it with raspberries.
    Beautiful strawberries on the mirror!

  39. Rose says:

    Congratulations Deborah. You really did an incredible job.

  40. Amy says:

    Your mirror is gorgeous! Great job with your first challenge!

  41. Peabody says:

    Excellent job with your cake. Way to step up to your first challenge.

  42. Quellia says:

    Nice job! Dishtowels work well, but so do paper towels! Welcome to the Daring Bakers!

  43. MyKitchenInHalfCups says:

    I’m in that boat with you, never even heard about a mirror cake let alone make one.
    Even with lumps it still looks good enough to eat! I had a lump here and there!

  44. Brilynn says:

    It looks like your first challenge was very successful!

  45. Beth G. says:

    Awesome!! You did a great job, and the photos are fantastic too~ I don’t know if I could make that!

  46. Culinarily Curious says:

    Another gorgeous “first challenge” mirror cake. Congratulations!

  47. Kristen says:

    You broke in your new KA perfectly! I love the slideshow.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>